A water-supply tunnel on the island of Hawaiʻi yielded fragile goose bones below ancient lava. They became the first fossil bird described from the Hawaiian Islands. Decades later, much younger fossils from lava tubes helped connect the discovery to a giant flightless member of the goose genus Branta.
Quick facts
| Family | Anatidae |
|---|---|
| Known from | Island of Hawaiʻi |
| Fossil material | Shin bone from Pāhala and later lava-tube remains |
| Holotype | USNM V16740, fragmentary right tibiotarsus |
| Locomotion | Terrestrial, with flightlessness inferred from later bones |
| Scientific name | Branta rhuax |
| Original name | Geochen rhuax |
| Lava above the type | 9170 ± 100 radiocarbon years before present |
What can the fossils tell us?
Cracks, distortion and fragility are consistent with heating. The condition of the bone leaves the goose’s cause of death unknown.
The lava provides a minimum age. The interval between the goose’s death and burial beneath the flow remains unknown.
Ancient mitochondrial DNA places the younger fossils among Hawaiian Branta geese. Olson later linked the older type using skeletal comparisons.
The Pāhala tunnel discovery
In 1926, work on a water-supply tunnel above Pāhala exposed bones near Kaumaikeohu. W. O. Clark sent them through the United States Geological Survey to the national museum. The bones lay near the top of an ash bed beneath several tens of metres of lava. Their cracking, warping and friability suggest exposure to intense heat.
Alexander Wetmore described Geochen rhuax in 1943. The fragmentary right tibiotarsus, USNM V16740, is the holotype. Parts of both femora and the pelvis also came from the discovery. A stout bridge over a tendon canal helped prompt a comparison with the Cape Barren goose. In 1991, Storrs Olson and Helen James judged the material too incomplete to establish that affinity reliably.
A date for the lava
Olson’s 2013 study cited a radiocarbon age of 9170 ± 100 years before present for the flow immediately above the type. The bones were already there when the flow covered them. The date therefore provides a minimum age for the fossil.
Further remains of giant geese occur in much younger Holocene lava-tube deposits on the western side of the island. The bird has also been identified from the southeastern side. The newer specimens preserve a much broader range of skeletal elements than the Pāhala fragments.

The change from Geochen to Branta
Ellen Paxinos and colleagues included bones from three younger giant geese in a study of ancient mitochondrial DNA. The giant goose belongs to a Hawaiian lineage derived from the Canada goose branch. The surviving nēnē is another member of that island lineage.
The Pāhala type is somewhat smaller than the younger specimens. Comparing the bones, Olson assigned them to the same species lineage and adopted the combination Branta rhuax. The genetic result applies to the younger material. In a separate Hawaiian lineage, the flightless Thambetochen was related to dabbling ducks. These island birds acquired large bodies and reduced flight independently.
The later giant-geese material shows a robust skull and bill and reduced wings. Skeletal proportions support flightlessness. The Pāhala type is principally a leg bone, so the reconstruction of the head relies on better-preserved material from the younger population.
Frequently asked questions
What is the scientific name of the giant Hawaiʻi goose?
Olson placed it in Branta as Branta rhuax in 2013. Wetmore’s original name for the fossil was Geochen rhuax.
How old is the bone below the lava?
The overlying flow gave a radiocarbon age of 9170 ± 100 years before present. The fossil lies below it and may be older.
Could the giant goose fly?
The younger material combines a heavy body with reduced wings, and the goose is generally interpreted as flightless.
Which living goose is related to it?
Ancient mitochondrial DNA puts it in the Hawaiian lineage that includes the living nēnē, Branta sandvicensis.

