Khuffia

Two types of small tooth from a Permian storm bed can be told apart by the height and spacing of their cusps.

Artistic view of a shallow Permian sea in what is now Oman
Artistic reconstruction of a shallow marine setting in the Middle Permian of what is now Oman.

One limestone bed in Oman yielded the type teeth of two species of Khuffia. Both had a continuous edge running across the crown, but they differ in the height of the main cusp and the spacing of the smaller points beside it. The isolated teeth record part of the feeding apparatus of this Permian cartilaginous fish.

Quick facts

GroupElasmobranchs
Family in the original descriptionSphenacanthidae
Type speciesKhuffia lenis
Type specimenTooth MPUM 10882
LocalityHaushi Cliff, Oman
AgeWordian, Middle Permian
FossilsComplete and fragmentary teeth
Evidence guide

What can the fossils tell us?

Both type teeth came from the same sample

Sample AO40 came from the top of a shell-rich storm layer. A storm deposit may mix remains from more than one local habitat.

A shell-rich layer at Haushi Cliff

Martha Koot, Gilles Cuny, Andrea Tintori and Richard Twitchett described Khuffia in a journal issue dated 2013. Its name comes from the Khuff Formation. Both type teeth came from sample AO40 at Haushi Cliff, in central eastern Oman. That sample represents the upper part of a storm bed rich in brachiopod shells.

The researchers used buffered acetic acid to free the small fossils from the limestone. The type specimens are held at the Palaeontological Museum of the University of Milan. The wider Khuff assemblage also includes the tall, triangular teeth of Glikmanius. The two genera illustrate how different the teeth of cartilaginous fishes in the same basin could be.

How the two species differ

The sample of Khuffia lenis contains 79 complete and broken teeth. The teeth measure 1.0–1.2 millimetres along the row and 0.5–0.6 millimetres in height. Teeth identified as front teeth usually have two pairs of blunt side cusplets, while lateral teeth carry three. A small projection lies on the inner face below the main cusp. The name lenis refers to a surface that is nearly smooth, although weak vertical ridges can be present.

The authors assigned 27 complete and broken teeth to Khuffia prolixa. At 1.3–1.6 millimetres along the row and 0.7–0.8 millimetres high, its teeth are longer and taller. They have one or two pairs of side cusplets with wider gaps between those cusplets and the main point. The inner projection seen in the type species is absent.

Artistic comparison of two Khuffia tooth shapes
Artistic comparison of a lower central cusp at left and a taller cusp with more widely separated side points at right.

What the roots contribute to classification

The base of a Khuffia tooth extends towards the inside of the mouth and has openings of unequal size. The authors found similarities to Sphenacanthus, while noting that Khuffia has weaker crown ornament, more distinct cusplets and fewer but larger openings in the base. They assigned the genus to Sphenacanthidae and left its order open.

The loose teeth give no secure body length, fin shape or complete tooth arrangement. Shell fragments in the storm bed record invertebrates in the basin. They do not show what Khuffia ate.

Frequently asked questions

Where did the name Khuffia come from?

It was named for Oman’s Khuff Formation.

Where is the type of the second species kept?

Tooth MPUM 10892 is held at the Palaeontological Museum of the University of Milan.

How old is the type bed?

It is Wordian, part of the Middle Permian.

Do all teeth of the type species have the same number of cusplets?

Front teeth were described with two pairs. Lateral teeth commonly carry three.