Palaeocircus

One wing bone from the gypsum of Montmartre still leaves the bird’s family open.

An artist’s impression of a shallow basin in the late Eocene
An artist’s impression of a late Eocene basin. The surviving bone does not establish the bird’s appearance.

Palaeocircus cuvieri is an Eocene bird of prey named from a fragmentary wing bone in the gypsum of Montmartre, Paris. The fossil prompted a comparison with ospreys. Disagreement over that comparison has kept the bird’s family uncertain.

Quick facts

SpeciesPalaeocircus cuvieri
GroupBird of prey, family uncertain
Age of the typeLate Eocene
Type localityMontmartre, Paris
Type materialRight carpometacarpus, MNHN 7988
Named byAlphonse Milne-Edwards, 1871
Evidence guide

What can the fossils tell us?

Part of the fused hand survives

MNHN 7988 preserves part of a right carpometacarpus. Its size and structure can be compared with living birds, but the fossil cannot give a wingspan.

A name from the gypsum of Montmartre

Georges Cuvier illustrated the fossil and compared its size to that of an osprey. Alphonse Milne-Edwards established Palaeocircus cuvieri in 1871 and named it for Cuvier. The name-bearing specimen, MNHN 7988, is held in the Muséum national d’Histoire naturelle in Paris. A carpometacarpus is the fused bone of the hand that helps support the feathers at the end of the wing.

Some historical inventories also list toe bones. The information available on those bones falls short of a securely associated skeleton, so the wing and its joints are discussed from the incomplete carpometacarpus.

An imagined fragment of bone exposed in gypsum
An artist’s impression of bone preserved in gypsum. The museum specimen is not reproduced.

How the family assignment changed

Jean Brunet interpreted the French bird as an osprey in 1970. Storrs Olson pointed out that the unions between the second and third metacarpals extend farther than in living Pandion, at both ends of the bone. His 1985 review left the bird without a family assignment. An older placement among hawks and their relatives likewise provides little basis for estimating how it fed.

An Eocene claw bone from Hordle, England, has also been attributed to Palaeocircus. With different parts of the skeleton preserved in France and England, that identification cannot be checked by matching the same element. Milvoides, a separate Hampshire raptor known from a foot bone, presents another case where an isolated element gives limited evidence about family affinities.

Frequently asked questions

Did it take fish like an osprey?

No fossil establishes a fish diet. The osprey identification was proposed from an incomplete wing bone.

Where did the type come from?

The late Eocene gypsum historically quarried on Montmartre, in present-day Paris.

What does the species name commemorate?

The name cuvieri honours Georges Cuvier, who illustrated and discussed the fossil before it received its scientific name.

Which part of the wing survives?

The specimen is an incomplete carpometacarpus from the right hand, near the outer end of the wing.