Paraorthacodus: a multi-cusped shark with one rare skeleton

Two Nusplingen fossils preserve parts of P. jurensis, while most species remain known from teeth alone.

Paraorthacodus jurensis reconstructed in a Late Jurassic sea
The body is an artistic reconstruction based on the Nusplingen fossils; colour and soft tissues are not preserved.

Paraorthacodus is an extinct shark genus recognised mainly from isolated teeth. Those teeth occur in marine deposits from the Early Jurassic to Paleocene, although the earliest and latest records depend on how fragmentary crowns are identified. The Late Jurassic species P. jurensis from Nusplingen, Germany, provides an unusually informative view of the body because two specimens preserve parts of its skeleton.

Quick facts

GenusParaorthacodus Glickman, 1957
Type speciesP. recurvus, first described as Sphenodus recurvus
GroupNeoselachian shark; later classifications use Paraorthacodontidae
Known recordEarly Jurassic teeth to Paleocene reports; the endpoints depend on identification
Best-preserved speciesLate Jurassic P. jurensis from Nusplingen, Germany
Skeleton materialTwo Nusplingen specimens; most other records are isolated teeth
Vertebrae in SMNS 88987/1About 123 calcified centra; the rear of the tail is missing
Evidence guide

What do the fossils establish?

Most records are isolated crowns

A tall main cusp and smaller lateral cusplets are characteristic of many assigned teeth. Their number and shape vary along the jaw, and wear can erase small details, so a loose tooth may not identify a species with confidence.

A shark usually known from teeth

The name Paraorthacodus was established by Leonid Glickman in 1957. Its type species is P. recurvus, named by Trautschold in 1877 as Sphenodus recurvus from Cenomanian deposits of the Volga region. The type species determines how the genus name is applied; it is not the best-preserved skeleton in the group.

Most specimens assigned to Paraorthacodus are loose teeth recovered from marine strata. A tooth crown can survive after the shark’s less mineralised cartilage has disappeared, so teeth dominate the fossil record. Their shape varies from the front of the jaw to the sides and changes with wear. Researchers compare the main cusp, lateral cusplets, root and ornamentation before making a genus or species assignment.

Many crowns have a tall central cusp flanked by smaller cusplets, a pattern consistent with grasping and cutting animal prey. That functional reading does not identify a particular meal. No stomach contents are known from the Nusplingen skeletons.

What two Nusplingen fossils preserve

The holotype of P. jurensis, GPIT 1210/1, is incomplete. A second, much more complete specimen, SMNS 88987/1, was collected at Nusplingen and described with the holotype by Stefanie Klug, Jürgen Kriwet, Ronald Böttcher, Günter Schweigert and Gerd Dietl in 2009. The second fossil made it possible to study parts of the body behind the head and pectoral region.

Its vertebral column contains about 123 well-calcified centra. The origin of the caudal fin lies near the eightieth centrum, while the posterior-most vertebrae are absent. The fossil therefore records the position of the tail transition but does not give a complete tail or a secure total body length.

One spineless dorsal fin is preserved far back on the body. This is a direct observation on P. jurensis, not a feature that can be checked in every tooth-only species. Claspers, the paired male reproductive organs of sharks, are not preserved in either specimen; their absence from the fossils cannot establish the sex of the animals.

Artistic reconstruction of Paraorthacodus jurensis with a single rear-set dorsal fin
The reconstruction highlights the single spineless dorsal fin reported in the Nusplingen skeleton. Skin, colour and soft tissues are not preserved.

The number of lateral cusplets differs between the holotype and SMNS 88987/1. The 2009 authors suggested sexual dimorphism as one possible explanation. Individual variation, tooth position or other causes cannot be ruled out from two specimens, so the proposal remains tentative.

Classification and changing names

The 2009 description discussed Paraorthacodus within Palaeospinacidae. Subsequent work proposed Paraorthacodontidae for Paraorthacodus and Macrourogaleus. Later syntheses place these sharks among early neoselachians and discuss their relationships with synechodontiform groups. The family and higher-level arrangement reflect changing anatomical comparisons and phylogenetic analyses; they do not imply that the same fossil has changed.

The genus range is assembled from separate tooth records. Teeth assigned to it have been reported from Pliensbachian Early Jurassic deposits onward, while Paleocene reports extend some classifications beyond the Cretaceous. The boundaries remain sensitive to tooth identification and to the possibility that older teeth were reworked into younger sediment. A long genus-level range should not be read as the range of one species.

What the skeleton can and cannot show

The Nusplingen fossils support a reconstruction of one Late Jurassic species with a rear-set spineless dorsal fin and a well-calcified vertebral column. They do not preserve colour, skin texture, exact swimming speed or behaviour. A complete outline must combine the fossil with comparisons to other sharks, while much of that outline remains interpretive.

For comparison, Cretalamna and Cretoxyrhina are other fossil shark genera whose records include many isolated teeth. Similar preservation does not mean the animals had identical anatomy or close relationships; each fossil record has to be assessed on its own evidence.

Frequently asked questions

What did Paraorthacodus teeth look like?

Many assigned teeth have a tall central cusp with smaller cusplets on each side. Their form varies with jaw position and wear, so an isolated tooth may not establish a species.

Is a complete Paraorthacodus skeleton known?

Two specimens of the Late Jurassic species P. jurensis from Nusplingen preserve parts of the skeleton. The more complete one still lacks the rearmost tail vertebrae, and most other species are known from teeth.

How many dorsal fins did P. jurensis have?

The Nusplingen skeleton shows one spineless dorsal fin set far back on the body. This observation applies to P. jurensis, not automatically to every species assigned from teeth.

When did Paraorthacodus live?

Teeth assigned to the genus have been reported from the Early Jurassic through the Paleocene. The endpoints are uncertain because many records are isolated and some identifications have been revised.