Plesiocathartes

A fragmentary foot led to the first identification. More complete specimens changed it.

Artistic reconstruction of Plesiocathartes on a branch above Eocene Lake Messel
Artistic reconstruction inspired by the Messel material. Plumage colours are conjectural.

Plesiocathartes is a genus of fossil birds documented in Europe and North America. The original French fossil was compared with New World vultures. More complete material made it possible to compare the head, shoulder and legs with the living cuckoo-roller of Madagascar and the Comoros.

Quick facts

RelationshipsEarly branch of Leptosomiformes
AgeEocene records; type horizon unresolved
Type localityQuercy phosphorites, France
Further recordsMessel, London Clay and Green River
MaterialIsolated bones and articulated skeletons
Evidence guide

What can the fossils tell us?

A partial foot bone anchored the name

The type tarsometatarsus lacks the upper end, where channels and grooves for tendons can provide additional characters.

Why the French fossil was compared with vultures

In 1908 Claude Gaillard named Plesiocathartes europaeus from an incomplete tarsometatarsus recovered from the Quercy fissure fillings. The deposits span different ages and the exact horizon of the bone is unknown. The fossil was initially linked with New World vultures. Its missing upper end would have preserved additional features associated with the toe tendons.

The English bird Milvoides presented a similar difficulty because it was named on an incomplete foot bone. In Plesiocathartes, the availability of further species made it possible to test the older interpretation with a broader set of characters.

Skeletons on two continents

Two articulated skeletons from Messel in Germany have been referred to P. kelleri. Gerald Mayr described the species in 2002. The type, SMF-ME 3639, is held at Senckenberg. The skeletons let researchers compare limb proportions as well as individual surfaces of the foot bone.

In 2006 Ilka Weidig described P. wyomingensis and P. major from the Early Eocene Green River Formation of North America. Together with European fossils these birds document a much wider distribution for early cuckoo-roller relatives than for the living lineage. The known sites do not specify a route of dispersal.

An imagined Eocene lake in the Messel basin
An artistic view of Eocene Messel, where the lake deposits preserved articulated skeletons of Plesiocathartes.

What the London Clay added

Gerald Mayr and Andrew Kitchener described the English species P. insolitipes. Its quadrate, a bone that forms part of the jaw joint, resembles that of the cuckoo-roller in several details. The type specimen, NMS.Z.2021.40.36, also includes parts of the breastbone and foot. The widened ends of some toe bones distinguish it from the Messel and Green River forms. The lower end of its tarsometatarsus is 7.2 mm wide, compared with 6.2 mm in another Plesiocathartes specimen from the same site. These are measurements of the bone.

The articulated skeletons offer a starting point for reconstructing the bird’s general proportions. The artwork draws on those bones and comparison with the living cuckoo-roller. The colours and precise behaviour of the extinct species remain unknown.

Frequently asked questions

Which group does Plesiocathartes belong to?

It is interpreted as an early branch of the cuckoo-roller lineage.

Why is the age of the type species uncertain?

The type bone was not tied to a precise horizon within the Quercy fissure deposits, which span different ages.

Where are the more complete fossils from?

Articulated skeletons are known from Messel. North America’s Green River Formation has also produced skeletal material.

Did Plesiocathartes live in Madagascar?

The known fossils are from Europe and North America. Its living relative, the cuckoo-roller, occurs in Madagascar and the Comoros.