Telmabates

Long legs once suggested a flamingo. The shoulder and limbs placed it among early waterfowl.

Artist’s reconstruction of Telmabates wading
Artist’s reconstruction of Telmabates. The long legs follow the fossils, while bill shape and plumage are interpreted.

Telmabates antiquus was a long-legged waterbird from early Eocene Patagonia. Hildegarde Howard first interpreted it as an early relative of flamingos. Comparisons with North American Presbyornis later identified it as a presbyornithid, a member of an extinct family of waterfowl.

Quick facts

Type speciesTelmabates antiquus
FamilyPresbyornithidae
AgeEarly Eocene
LocalityCañadón Hondo, Chubut, Argentina
HolotypeAMNH 3170
MaterialPartial skeleton and referred bones
Evidence guide

What can the fossils tell us?

Wing and leg elements survive

The type material includes the humerus, ulna, radius, bones of the hand and part of the shin. Small skull pieces do not preserve the entire bill.

The Cañadón Hondo material

The Scarritt expedition led by George Gaylord Simpson recovered the fossils at Cañadón Hondo, south of the Río Chico. Howard named the species in 1955. Its type, AMNH 3170, is held at the American Museum of Natural History in New York.

The descriptions document about ninety mineralised bones and fragments, some distorted by preservation. They include bones of the limbs and shoulder girdle, fragments of the pelvis and skull, parts of the breastbone and vertebrae. Recent studies use the name Las Flores Formation for the early Eocene beds.

Artist’s impression of layered Patagonian clay and silt
An interpretive view of the kind of sediment in which bird fossils can occur, without depicting the actual findspot.

How a proposed flamingo became a waterfowl relative

The long legs prompted Howard’s comparison with flamingos. In 1974 Alan Feduccia and Paul McGrew pointed out a closer resemblance to Presbyornis. Per Ericson later retained Telmabates as a separate genus based on leg proportions and features of the coracoid. Shared features with the Australian Wilaru also helped document presbyornithids on both sides of the Southern Hemisphere.

The long legs fit a bird that could wade in shallow water. The skull fragments leave it unclear whether Telmabates strained food with its bill as proposed for Presbyornis. No complete bill is known.

Interpretive illustration of elongated fossil leg bones
An imagined comparison showing the general proportions of elongated leg bones.

Why the genus lost a second species

Joel Cracraft named Telmabates howardae in 1970 from part of a smaller bird’s shin bone from the same deposits. In 2024 Ricardo De Mendoza and colleagues moved it to the new genus Wunketru, citing differences around the lower joint. The family of that bird remains uncertain.

Frequently asked questions

Where was it found?

At Cañadón Hondo in the early Eocene Las Flores Formation of Chubut, southern Argentina.

Was Telmabates a flamingo?

Howard first proposed a flamingo affinity, but later comparisons placed it with presbyornithid waterfowl.

What distinguishes it from Presbyornis?

Its leg bones are stouter and differ in relative lengths. A ridge on the coracoid is also more prominent.

Can its bill shape be reconstructed precisely?

The fossil skull is fragmentary. The complete profile of the bill and how it was used remain uncertain.