Microsula

A history of small seabird bones whose classification is still debated.

An imagined small Miocene sulid on a marine shore
Artistic reconstruction of a small Miocene sulid. The precise appearance and plumage of Microsula are unknown.

Microsula is a name associated with small fossil sulids from Miocene seas. It brings together North American and European finds described at different times and classified in different ways. Their history shows why superficially similar seabird bones cannot be placed in one genus on size alone.

Quick facts

FamilySulidae
AgeMiocene
FindsNorth America and Europe
Main materialHumeri; also an attributed femur
Generic statusLimits and independence disputed
Evidence guide

What can the fossils tell us?

A Maryland humerus fragment

The name Microsula is tied to the species avita. Its holotype, USNM 13854, is the distal end of a right humerus from the Calvert Formation.

Wetmore’s American type specimen

In 1938, Alexander Wetmore described Sula (Microsula) avita, proposing Microsula as a subgenus of Sula. The holotype, USNM 13854, is the distal, or lower, end of a right humerus. W. G. Lynn collected it on 1 January 1934 near Plum Point, Maryland, in the Calvert Formation.

The material is held by the Smithsonian National Museum of Natural History. An incomplete humerus permits comparison of the elbow joint and aspects of wing proportions, but does not provide the length of an entire wing or its span. Its description as a small bird rests on comparison with other sulids rather than a complete preserved skeleton.

Wetmore also assigned the carpometacarpus USNM 15158 to the species. In his 1985 review, Storrs Olson noted that this wrist-and-hand bone belonged to a considerably larger sulid. Its anatomy therefore cannot simply be incorporated into a reconstruction of Microsula avita.

A French species and the Grund fossils

In 1874, Alphonse Milne-Edwards had described Sula pygmaea from a humerus found at Léognan in France. This species was subsequently included in Microsula as Microsula pygmaea. The French deposits are assigned to the Early Miocene.

In 2003, Ursula Göhlich described material from Grund in Lower Austria under that name: a left humerus, NHMW 2002z0132/0001, and a right femur, NHMW 2002z0132/0002. Both are held by the Natural History Museum in Vienna. The Austrian humerus measures 137.2 mm; this is a measurement of the actual bone, not an estimate of standing height.

The Grund beds are younger than the French occurrence and belong to the Middle Miocene. A 2013 treatment considered the temporal separation grounds for the more cautious identification Microsula cf. M. pygmaea. The abbreviation cf. indicates comparison with that species without claiming that the identification is conclusively established.

Why the genus changes between classifications

Microsula has been treated as a subgenus of Sula, a separate genus and a synonym of Morus, the genus containing living gannets. The French species pygmaea has also been placed in other genera; Enkurosula is one name encountered in the literature. These alternatives reflect reassessment of skeletal similarities, not the discovery of additional birds within a single specimen.

A list containing avita and pygmaea should therefore not be presented as a universally accepted, final classification. With isolated bones, it is difficult to distinguish generic characters from individual variation, growth-related differences or distinctions between species. Evaluation has to start with type specimens and directly comparable parts of the skeleton.

A marine bird with an incomplete life history

Sulids specialise in obtaining food at sea. Family affinity and wing anatomy make a flying, fish-eating seabird a reasonable general reconstruction for Microsula. Its exact hunting technique, diving depth and prey composition have not been directly established for the described specimens.

Other families also depended on water. For example, Borvocarbo has been assigned to the cormorant family; a similar environment does not make it a sulid. Joint surfaces and other skeletal details are more informative when distinguishing such fossils than a general marine lifestyle.

The artistic reconstruction presents only a possible appearance for a small sulid. Plumage colours, soft tissues of the head and feather details are unknown. The coastal illustration represents a marine setting rather than a documented colony or fossil nest.

An imagined Miocene marine shoreline
Artistic reconstruction of a marine coast associated with the broader Calvert fauna. This is not a photograph of a fossil locality or a particular bed.

Frequently asked questions

Is Microsula definitely a separate genus?

That depends on the classification used. It has been recognised independently, treated as a subgenus of Sula and combined with Morus. Its generic independence has received differing interpretations.

Which fossil anchors the name Microsula?

The type species avita is based on the distal right humerus USNM 13854 from Maryland. Use of the generic name must be evaluated in relation to that specimen.

Why is the Austrian identification qualified?

The remains resemble the French species pygmaea but come from younger deposits. A later treatment preferred a tentative identification using cf.

Can it be illustrated with modern gannet colours?

Its actual colours are unknown. Living sulids inform the general body plan, but copying the plumage of one modern species would remain an artistic assumption.