Parapalaeobates

A large Senegalese tooth preserves two kinds of ornament on a single crown. Wear and exceptional size make its species harder to identify.

Artistic macro illustration of the ornamented crown of a Parapalaeobates tooth
An artistic study of a broad ray tooth. The proportions, surface relief and scale are approximate.

Parapalaeobates was a Late Cretaceous ray known from broad, low teeth. A large example from Senegal carries a network of small cells along one edge and branching ridges along the other. The ornament and crown outline helped identify the genus, while wear complicated the species assignment.

Quick facts

GroupRays
Age of findsLate Cretaceous
Type speciesParapalaeobates pygmaeus
Recorded areasEgypt, Morocco, Senegal, Cabinda and Madagascar
Senegal toothCrown 18 × 7 mm, tooth height 8 mm
Evidence guide

What can the fossils tell us?

One crown preserves two kinds of ornament

A mesh on the outer edge and branching ridges towards the mouth help identify the genus.

How the teeth acquired a new genus

Alfred Quaas described teeth from the Overweg beds of the Libyan Desert in 1902 as Strophodus pygmaeus. Wilhelm Weiler established Parapalaeobates in 1930 for that species. The early name reflects the similarity between crushing teeth in distinct groups of cartilaginous fishes. Later studies place Parapalaeobates in an extinct family of rays.

A complete tooth from the Cabinda area was compared with the Egyptian type species in 1943. Edmond Dartevelle and Edgar Casier later reassigned that specimen to Parapalaeobates atlanticus, the species Camille Arambourg described from Moroccan fossils. The crest on the working surface mattered in that reassessment because the Egyptian material had a more prominent crest.

An unusually broad crown from Senegal

In 2012 Gilles Cuny, Jeremy Martin and Raphaël Sarr described specimen SN234 from Unit 3 of the Cap de Naze Formation. Viewed from the top, the crown forms an elongated hexagon. It is 18 mm along the jaw and 7 mm from the outer to the inner edge. The tooth is 8 mm high. Sediment conceals the lower part of the crown and most of the root.

The outer edge bears a reticulated pattern. Denser branching ridges cover the inner edge, and a shallow crest separates the two areas. The ornament resembles that of Igdabatis. The Indian species used in the comparison lacks that crest and has a less regular outline. SN234 resembles Moroccan Parapalaeobates teeth, but exceeds the usual width of about 10 mm. Its size and wear led the researchers to identify the genus alone.

Marine records and a crushing dentition

Palaeontologists also reported Parapalaeobates teeth from the upper Maastrichtian Berivotra Formation in the Mahajanga Basin of Madagascar. The island material and the Senegal tooth were both assigned at genus level. They document the ray in different marine basins and leave the ranges of individual species unresolved.

The broad, low crown could apply pressure across a relatively wide surface, a useful shape for crushing hard food. The teeth offer no direct record of particular prey. They also give little basis for determining body length or the outline of the fins.

Artistic illustration of a shallow seabed with sand and bivalves
An artistic shallow-water scene showing a possible setting for the ray.

Frequently asked questions

Why is Parapalaeobates classified as a ray?

The crown outline, ornament and other dental traits led researchers to place it in the extinct ray family Parapalaeobatidae.

Why did the Senegal tooth remain unnamed at species level?

It is worn and unusually large. The similarities to other material support the genus assignment.

Where was the genus found outside mainland Africa?

Teeth were reported from the upper Maastrichtian Berivotra Formation in Madagascar.

What might Parapalaeobates have eaten?

Its broad teeth were suitable for crushing hard food. The fossils do not identify particular prey.