Paraprefica

A well-preserved skull placed this German Eocene bird on the potoo branch of the avian family tree.

Artist’s reconstruction of Paraprefica on a branch at Messel
Artist’s reconstruction of Paraprefica at Lake Messel. Plumage, posture and lighting are conjectural.

Paraprefica was an Eocene relative of modern potoos. Two species are known from the Messel Pit in Germany, and one preserves a skull complete enough to test an early suggestion that it belonged near oilbirds. The fossils show that an early branch of the modern American potoo family once lived in Europe.

Quick facts

Type speciesParaprefica kelleri
Other speciesParaprefica major
AffinitiesEarly branch of the potoo family
AgeEocene, about 48 million years ago
LocalityMessel Pit, Germany
Type specimenSMF-ME 3376
Complete skeletonSMF-ME 3727a+b
Evidence guide

What can the fossils tell us?

Skull and limbs from the same bird

Both sides of the slab of SMF-ME 3727 retain parts of a complete skeleton. The skull makes features available that were difficult to assess from the type.

Two species in an Eocene lake deposit

Gerald Mayr named Paraprefica kelleri and P. major in 1999. The type of P. kelleri, SMF-ME 3376, is a partial skeleton. The more complete skeleton SMF-ME 3727a+b later provided a well-preserved skull along with the rest of the body. The two suffixes refer to the two sides of the split slab.

The type material of P. major, SMNS 81654, preserves the front of the skeleton. Another skull of that species confirmed that enlarged palatal bones were a feature of the genus. Both species occur in the same Messel lake deposits, which accumulated over a span of time.

Illustrated delicate bird skeleton preserved in a slab
A generic interpretation of bird preservation in Messel oil shale. It does not depict a named specimen.

A skull with a different combination of traits

Mayr originally associated Paraprefica with the North American fossil Prefica and the oilbird lineage. His later analysis of 98 skeletal traits supported living potoos as the closest living relatives, while Prefica still grouped with the oilbird. Some similarities of the two fossil genera may come from a common ancestor farther down the tree.

Compared with present-day potoos, Paraprefica had a longer bill relative to the rest of the head, lacked their tooth-like projection along the upper jaw and had a slender carpometacarpus, the fused bone in the hand of the wing. Thiago Costa and colleagues proposed the extinct subfamily Parapreficinae for the Messel species in 2021.

The setting at Messel

The fossils occur in the finely layered deposits of a volcanic crater lake. Oxygen-poor conditions near the lake floor helped delicate skeletons survive. The colour of the reconstructed bird is conjectural and the skeleton gives no direct record of when it hunted. Potoos belong to a broader group that also includes swifts and hummingbirds. The fossil hummingbird Eurotrochilus illustrates the very different specialisations reached on a separate branch.

A reconstruction of a forested Eocene crater lake
An artist’s reconstruction of the Messel lake and its surroundings.

Frequently asked questions

Which species are known?

Paraprefica kelleri and P. major. Both are from the Eocene of Messel, Germany.

Why was the complete skull important?

It revealed features of the jaws and palate that could be compared with living potoos and the oilbird.

Do potoos live in Europe today?

Living potoos are restricted to the tropical Americas. The Messel birds belong to an extinct European branch.

Are Paraprefica and Prefica close relatives?

They were once grouped together, but a later skeletal analysis placed Paraprefica with potoos and Prefica with the oilbird lineage.