Protoxynotus

Two teeth from Misburg gave this shark its name. Other finds revealed what the upper jaw may have done and extended its range across the Cretaceous Tethys.

Artist’s impression of a Cretaceous marine shelf with a marl seafloor
An imagined Cretaceous marine shelf. Teeth assigned to the genus occur in sediments from several shelf settings.

In 1975 Jacques Herman named Protoxynotus from two incomplete teeth found at Misburg near Hanover. Both were assigned to the lower jaw. Teeth of a strikingly different shape circulated under another name until a comparison of material from Germany and Austria showed how the two jaws of this Cretaceous shark could have served different purposes.

Quick facts

AgeTuronian to Maastrichtian, Late Cretaceous
GroupDogfish sharks
MaterialIsolated upper and lower teeth
LocalitiesGermany, Austria and Lebanon
AffinitiesDental evidence links it to sleeper sharks
Evidence guide

What can the fossils tell us?

The Misburg holotype is a lower tooth

Specimen kca 8 comes from Campanian deposits. It preserves features of the crown and root that can be compared with other lower teeth. The upper row had to be worked out from separate material.

Two names for material from Germany

The type species, Protoxynotus misburgensis, takes its name from Misburg. Its holotype, kca 8, is interpreted as a tooth from the centre of the lower jaw. The crown margin looked faintly serrated in the original description. A later examination attributed the irregularity to damage.

Detlev Thies and Müller described teeth from nearby Höver in 1993. The material later became known as Paraphorosoides ursulae. In 2022 a team led by Ivo Feichtinger compared the crowns, grooves and openings in their roots and assigned the Höver material to the same species as the Misburg specimens. The earlier name, Protoxynotus, has priority.

Gripping teeth and cutting teeth

The presumed upper teeth are narrow and needle-like. The lower teeth are compressed from front to back and bear a broader cutting edge with a relatively upright cusp. The revision proposes that the upper row could hold prey while the lower row cut it. The fossils leave the identity of that prey open.

Upper and lower teeth also differ in Proetmopterus. In that shark the main cusp of the lower teeth tips much farther to one side. Differences of this kind help palaeontologists distinguish isolated teeth and examine how the jaws might have worked.

Artistic comparison of a narrow upper Protoxynotus tooth and a flattened lower tooth
An artistic comparison of a narrow upper tooth and a flattened cutting tooth from the lower jaw. Relative sizes are illustrative.

From a Turonian tooth to the end of the Cretaceous

The oldest record is a single Turonian tooth from Wüllen in north-western Germany. It was tentatively assigned to a form close to the Misburg species. Campanian teeth occur in northern Germany and Bavaria. A Santonian occurrence in Lebanon shows that the Misburg species also reached the southern margin of the Tethys.

In Austria, 250 kilograms of marl from the Waidach section produced seven teeth, three complete and four fragmentary. They came from a level 1.25 metres below a gap in the sediments that spans the Cretaceous–Palaeogene boundary. The holotype of P. mayrmelnhoffi, NHMW/2021/0116/0001, is in the Natural History Museum Vienna. Teeth of this species reach no more than 1.8 millimetres in height.

A relative of sleeper sharks

Herman originally compared the lower teeth with those of living roughsharks. The upper teeth broadened the comparison. In the 2022 phylogenetic analysis, the nearest living lineage sampled was Zameus, a sleeper shark. Both species of Protoxynotus are known from isolated teeth. Body length and fin shape remain unknown.

Frequently asked questions

When did Protoxynotus live?

The genus occurs in several Late Cretaceous stages, from the Turonian to the Maastrichtian.

Why did the Höver material change names?

The 2022 revision recognised the same combination of crown and root features in both the Höver and Misburg material. The older name takes priority.

Were its teeth serrated?

The apparent serrations on the holotype were attributed to damage when it was re-examined. Well-preserved cutting edges are smooth.

What did it eat?

Its exact diet is unknown. The narrow upper teeth and blade-like lower teeth suggest how it could have held and cut prey.